How much does one missed exclusion check really cost?

Most clinics don't learn how much they've lost the hard way. They usually learn when an auditor reviews the patient rosters, checks the patients' names against the federal exclusion list, and then asks why the excluded individual has been billing Medicare for the past eight months.

At that point, it's no longer "should we have checked?" – it's "how much do we owe?"

The number everyone quoted (and what it actually is)

As mentioned above, if you hire or contract with a provider who is listed on the OIG exclusion list, and you either knowingly employed them or should have known better, the maximum civil monetary penalty is $25,595 for each item or service billed while that person was excluded. In addition to this CMP, the OIG may impose an assessment of up to three (3) times the amount of the claim(s). This is based on the claim volume, not the individual. For example, ten claims at the maximum would equal $255,950 before any multiplier — not a prediction of what any given practice will owe, just what the ceiling looks like once you multiply by volume. A clinician excluded for several months could easily have multiple claims attached to their name.

Plus money back to Medicare

Penalties are not the complete bill. As the OIG's own rule on exclusions states, no payment may be made by a federal health care program for any item or service furnished by an excluded person, directly or indirectly. So any claim tied to that person wasn't a valid payment in the first place. It's an overpayment, and overpayments get returned, on top of whatever CMP exposure comes with them. The OIG's Provider Self-Disclosure Protocol exists for exactly this: a practice that catches the problem itself can disclose it and negotiate the repayment, rather than wait for an auditor to find it first.

And then there's the False Claims Act

OIG assessments aren't the only exposure here. The False Claims Act ("FCA") can reach the same claims, with its own penalties and treble damages, when the knew-or-should-have-known standard is met. Proving intent to defraud isn't required. A claim submitted after you knew, or should have known, that the person who furnished the service was excluded can satisfy the FCA's "knowing" standard.

"We check sometimes" won't cut it

Another surprise for many practices: there's no specific statutory requirement to run LEIE checks on a fixed schedule. OIG says so directly. But the list updates monthly, and OIG's own guidance says monthly screening "best minimizes potential overpayment and CMP liability." Having checked six months ago tells an auditor nothing about the five months since. The "knew or should have known" standard doesn't care that you checked once — it cares whether you had a current, reasonable way to know, and whether you used it.

This is also where a federal-only habit falls short. A number of states run their own Medicaid exclusion list on top of the LEIE, built under the state's own authority. A clean federal result says nothing about a state list you never checked.

The fix costs minutes a month, not six figures

None of this requires a compliance department. It requires a habit: run the roster against the federal LEIE and against the exclusion list for every state you bill Medicaid in, on a schedule you can point to, and keep the dated result. That habit is what turns "we should have known" into "we checked, and here's when."

CredGuard's free single-name LEIE lookup is live right now: paste a name, get a federal exclusion result in seconds, no signup. Check a name free → If you've never run a check at all, start there, or walk through the full process in our guide on checking the LEIE.

For a whole roster, checking every name against every list by hand, every month, is the part that quietly stops happening. CredGuard's monthly roster monitoring, covering the federal LEIE and state Medicaid exclusion lists with an audit-ready record on file, is in early access now. Reserve your spot →

FAQ

Is $25,595 the total I'd owe for one excluded employee?

It's the maximum penalty per item or service billed while that person was excluded, not a flat per-person fine. A clinician with a high claim volume during the exclusion period carries far more exposure than one with a handful of claims, and OIG can add an assessment of up to three times the amount claimed on top.

Do I have to pay back money I already billed?

If the payment was for something an excluded person furnished, OIG's rule is that no federal program payment may be made for it in the first place. That makes it an overpayment, separate from any civil penalty.

Does the False Claims Act really apply here?

It can. A claim for services you knew or should have known weren't payable is the same conduct the False Claims Act targets, and its penalties run alongside whatever OIG assesses under its own exclusion authority.

What if we find the problem ourselves, before an audit does?

OIG's Provider Self-Disclosure Protocol exists for practices that catch this on their own and want to resolve the overpayment and CMP exposure directly, rather than wait to be audited.

Is the monthly roster monitoring live yet?

Not yet. It's in early access. The free single-name federal LEIE lookup is live today.